Strengthening protections against unfair contract terms: Comments on Treasury exposure draft legislation
This joint submission contains feedback on Treasury’s proposed reforms to unfair contract term (UCT) protections for consumers and small businesses from Consumer Action Law Centre, Financial Rights Legal Centre, Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service, Residents of Retirement Villages Victoria and WEstjustice.
Our organisations have all long advocated for UCTs to be made illegal, to provide greater incentive for businesses to stop using them, and to provide real avenues for consumers to seek redress if they are used.
UCTs are, by definition, unreasonable and unnecessary. There is no justification for businesses to be using them in their standard form contracts, to the detriment of consumers. Using and relying on UCTs should carry a substantial penalty. We accordingly welcomed the November 2020 commitment by Commonwealth, State and Territory ministers to deliver on the recommendations from Treasury’s final Regulation Impact Statement for the enhancements to unfair contract term protections (RIS).
We strongly support the content of the Exposure Draft Treasury Laws Amendment Measures for a later sitting) Bill 2021: Unfair contract terms reforms (the Draft Bill), and the Explanatory Memorandum (Draft EM). The proposed legislation would give the UCT regime teeth and go a long way towards completing the UCT reform process that has taken well over 10 years. That said, there are still some ways the Draft Bill could be improved, particularly with regard to access to justice for consumers and small businesses. The regime changes proposed by the Draft Bill would still rely heavily on judgments of the court for just outcomes to be delivered to all consumers impacted by UCTs.
Our recommendations are primarily aimed at ensuring that the Draft Bill makes relief for losses caused by UCTs to be more accessible and ensuring that the regime does not unintentionally have any adverse impact upon consumers or small businesses who have suffered loss as a result of UCTs.
Overall, we encourage the Government to introduce the Bill to Parliament as soon as possible and pass the legislation.
Read the full submission and full list of recommendations (PDF).